• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
eco-jurisprudence monitor logo

Eco Jurisprudence Monitor

  • EJ Tracker
    • Report Initiative
    • Tracker FAQ
    • Codebook
    • Printable Charts
    • Data Ethics
    • Data Request
  • Resources
    • Eco Jurisprudence Tracker
    • Legal Toolkit
  • About
    • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Contact
  • English
    • Español

Ecuador Cofán Sinangoe Case

Ecuador
National
Approved in 2022
Case
Rights Of Nature
Nature
All Nature
Representatives of the A'L Cofán Sinangoe people
Indigenous

Summary

Representatives of the A’L Cofán Sinangoe people presented a protective action to suspend several mining concessions granted in the riverside areas of the Aguarico, Chingual, and Cofanes. The action was accepted by a constitutional judge, who declared the mining activities threatened their collective right to prior consultation. They also refer to the right to territory, nature, and water. The judge also referenced the need to protect Cayambe-Coca National Park. The first-level sentence was appealed by state entities, but the appeal was rejected by the Appeals Chamber. It also declared that the rights of the A’L Cofán Sinangoe people to water, a healthy environment, culture, and territory were violated as well as rights of nature. The case was appealed to the Constitutional Court, which used the case to establish binding jurisprudence on the question of indigenous communities’ right to prior informed consent. The Court issued its ruling in 2022 and ruled that an Indigenous community’s right to free, prior and informed consultation was violated by oil projects and called for stronger protections to guarantee Indigenous communities’ rights to decide over extractive projects in their territories. As part of the ruling, the judges said indigenous communities must not only be consulted about extractive projects on or near their territory, but they must also give their consent to such projects. The ruling will immediately affect oil and mining projects across the country, as they must now seek the consent of indigenous communities who might be affected by their activities.

To see the original legal document(s) for this initiative, click the links below:

Cofan Sinangoe Case First Judgment [PDF]
Cofan Sinangoe Case Appeals Judgment [PDF]

To see other supplementary information related to this initiative, click the links below:

Ecuador’s top court rules for stronger land rights for Indigenous communities
All Eyes on the Amazon

When using our data, please follow the FAIR and CARE Principles for data governance outlined in our Ethics Statement. We are doing our best to be correct in the information we provide, but if you notice any omission or inaccuracy, please report this to us immediately at info@ecojurisprudence.org so we can correct it.

Eco Jurisprudence Tracker is licensed under CC BY 4.0

Footer

Contact

  • EJ Tracker
  • Resources
  • About
earth law center
UN Harmony with Nature
Ecological Law and Governance Association
GARN logo
Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund

Subscribe to our newsletter:

Privacy Policy

© 2023 Eco Jurisprudence Monitor – all rights reserved.

  • English
  • Español